NIMBA COUNTY, Liberia — A hung jury has delayed justice in the rape case involving three minor children, as Judge Musa S. Sidibey, Resident Circuit Judge of the Sexual Offenses Division Court at the 8th Judicial Circuit in Nimba County, has commenced a new trial against 33-year-old Franklin Manteh.

The retrial follows a 5-7 split verdict during the August 2026 Term of Court, when a 12-member jury failed to reach a unanimous decision, with five jurors voting not guilty and seven voting guilty. This forced the court to return the case to its docket in accordance with Liberia’s Criminal Procedure Law.

The new trial commenced Monday, November 16, 2026, during the seventh day’s jury sitting of the November 2026 Term, with the prosecution having already presented five witnesses, including two of the alleged child victims and the parents of all three children.

Manteh, whom Nimba County Public Defender Cllr Aaron D. Kartee represents, declined to enter a plea during his arraignment; Judge Sidibey treated the refusal as a plea of not guilty and proceeded with the empanelment of a new 12-member jury. The alleged incidents occurred on March 17 and March 22, 2026, in Dahnlorpa Community, Sanniquellie City, and Manteh remains presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.

Following the jury’s inability to reach the required threshold for a valid verdict, Manteh’s defense counsel requested that the court formally record the matter as a hung jury and order a new trial. The Sexual Offenses Division Court subsequently ordered the case returned to its docket for retrial in accordance with Liberia’s Criminal Procedure Law.

After the reading of the indictment by the Clerk of Court during his arraignment, Manteh reportedly declined to enter a plea, expressing his unwillingness to be tried before the court.
Ruling on the defendant’s refusal to plead, Judge Sidibey explained that the defense had previously filed a motion for a change of venue, which was duly heard and denied by the court.

The judge further noted that following the denial, defense counsel took exception to the ruling and indicated an intention to take advantage of the applicable statutory provisions. However, the court treated the defendant’s refusal to enter a plea as a plea of not guilty, allowing the proceedings to continue with the empanelment of a new 12-member trial jury.

The prosecution team from the Ministry of Justice is represented by Atty. Joseph G. Suah.
During the ongoing retrial, the prosecution has presented five witnesses, including two of the alleged child victims and the parents of all three children, who have testified before the court.

Details of the Indictment

The Ministry of Justice indicted Manteh on the charge of rape, a felony of the first degree, in connection with allegations involving three minor children in the Dahnlorpa Community, Sanniquellie City. The indictment alleges that on March 17, 2026, at approximately 1:45 p.m., Manteh intentionally and unlawfully sexually abused two children, identified by their initials as I.T., 6, and T.W., 9.

It further alleges that Manteh placed the two children on his lap, offered them biscuits, and subsequently penetrated them with his fingers.
The indictment also details a separate allegation involving a third child, identified as S.M., aged two years and four months, the child of Evelyn Saye and Emmanuel Manteh, Sr.

According to the prosecution, the alleged incident occurred on March 22, 2026, when Manteh was bathing the child after she had defecated on herself. Police investigations conducted through the Sex Crimes Investigation Unit of the Women and Children Protection Section (WACPS) of the Liberia National Police reportedly established allegations that Manteh sexually molested and abused the three children.

However, Manteh has categorically denied sexually abusing or molesting any of the alleged victims. The indictment indicates that although he acknowledged having contact with the children, he denied engaging in sexual intercourse with them.

Medical Evidence Presented During First Trial

During the first trial in September 2026, the prosecution also presented a medical report from the Ministry of Health, prepared by the Sexual and Gender-Based Violence (SGBV) Unit of G.W. Harley Hospital.

According to the report, physical examinations of the alleged victims’ genital areas documented findings that the examining medical personnel considered relevant to the allegations.
The report described the vaginal area as appearing red rather than its normal pink coloration and indicated that the hymen was absent. It further attributed the reported findings to penetration by fingers.

The medical report formed part of the evidence presented during the first trial, which ultimately ended in a hung jury after the jurors failed to reach a unanimous decision. With the commencement of the retrial, the case is now before a newly constituted 12-member jury, as the prosecution and defense prepare to present their respective positions for the court’s determination.

The case has drawn attention to the importance of accountability, the protection of children from sexual violence, and the need for timely judicial proceedings in cases involving alleged sexual offenses against minors.
Meanwhile, Manteh remains presumed innocent under the law unless and until proven guilty by the competent court of jurisdiction.

Leave a Comment

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *